For commercial properties across America, adequate wildfire coverage under an all-risk property policy is becoming harder to secure. In today’s market, wildfire risks can carry very different deductibles and retention requirements, which can vary significantly from carrier to carrier. For wholesale brokers working with retail agents to place a client’s coverage, these differences make the deductible a key factor in deciding whether a property program fits an insured’s financial resources.
For small and mid-sized businesses, a large wildfire deductible can draw on the same cash reserves needed to repair damaged property, support employees, and restore operations after a fire. When the available terms leave a business retaining more risk than it can comfortably afford, brokers need a way to address that exposure within the existing program.
Wildfire Deductible Buyback offers a novel and focused way to address that exposure. A separate indemnity policy can cover a portion of the wildfire deductible, helping brokers reduce their client’s share of the risk while keeping the overlying property carrier’s required retention in place.
In this issue
Why wildfire exposure deserves attention beyond traditional California placements
How Wildfire Deductible Buyback reduces retained exposure within an existing property program
What brokers should evaluate at renewal
The Geography of Wildfire Exposure is Changing
One of the biggest misconceptions is that wildfire is just a California problem, and for good reason. California’s concentration of property values, historical wildfire losses, regulatory environment, and carrier experience make the state the largest addressable market for wildfire risks. However, we believe that using California as shorthand for the entire US wildfire problem misses where property exposure is accumulating and where insurers are evaluating the peril.

Cotality's 2026 Wildfire Risk Report summarizes the broader exposure: More than 2.5 million properties across the 10 most exposed western states have moderate or greater wildfire risk, representing nearly $1.4 trillion in reconstruction cost value. California remains the largest individual concentration, but 49.9% of those at-risk properties are outside California.
The distribution outside California is substantial enough to matter on its own. Colorado and Texas together account for nearly 560,000 at-risk properties and $252 billion in reconstruction cost value. At the metropolitan level, four of Cotality's 10 most exposed markets are outside California, with Austin leading the group at more than 100,000 at-risk properties and $49.2 billion in reconstruction cost value.
As of October 24, 2026, 65,796 wildfires have been reported nationwide, burning more than 9.1 million acres, with acres burned running at 143% of the 10-year year-to-date average. While burned acreage is useful context, where the fire occurs, how quickly it spreads, and how much property lies in its path can matter considerably more to insured loss than the total number of acres burned. KatRisk and Technosylva’s 2026 wildfire analysis points to 2025 as an example: global burned area was the second lowest since 2002, yet insured wildfire losses reached a record $40–41 billion. The report also cites research showing that fires growing faster than 4,003 acres per day represented just 2.7% of fires but accounted for 88% of homes destroyed.

While these figures illustrate a snapshot rather than a ranking of long-term wildfire risk, what is becoming clear is how wildfire risk is increasingly now a national problem. As commercial carriers refine wildfire underwriting at the individual-location and portfolio level, brokers should expect insurance implications, including wildfire-specific retentions, to become relevant in markets that may not historically have been treated as "wildfire accounts."
How Wildfire Deductible Buyback works
Wildfire Deductible Buyback addresses a specific part of the property program rather than replacing it. The overlying property carrier establishes the wildfire deductible it is prepared to offer, while a separate buyback policy insures a defined portion of the amount the insured would otherwise retain.
Consider a commercial property with a $500,000 wildfire deductible. The client may be comfortable retaining the first $50,000 of a wildfire loss but may not want $500,000 of balance-sheet exposure. A Wildfire Deductible Buyback policy could be structured to cover the $450,000 between the client's desired retention and the deductible on the underlying property program. On a sufficiently large covered wildfire loss, the structure could work as follows:
Insured retention: $50,000
Wildfire Deductible Buyback: $450,000
Overlying property policy: responds above the $500,000 wildfire deductible
Conceptually, the structure allows two distinct underwriting decisions to coexist: the primary carrier can retain the wildfire deductible it considers appropriate, while the insured can make a separate decision about how much of that deductible it actually wants to finance.
Wildfire Deductible Buyback can potentially solve 5 distinct challenges presented to commercial insureds:
1. A more predictable out-of-pocket exposure
For the insured, the most immediate benefit is greater certainty around the amount of wildfire loss it may have to fund. A large wildfire deductible represents a contingent obligation that may sit quietly on the balance sheet until the business is dealing with a significant property event.
For SMEs in particular, the business can be adequately insured above its wildfire deductible and still face a meaningful liquidity problem below it, especially if the same event interrupts revenue or creates immediate operating expenses.
Reducing a potential $500,000 retention to $50,000 does not eliminate the insured's participation in the loss. It does, however, replace a substantially larger first-dollar exposure with an amount management may be better able to budget for, reserve against, and absorb without disrupting other uses of capital.

2. A way to address lender and contractual requirements
The amount of wildfire risk an insured is willing to retain isn’t always the only consideration. Commercial lenders, lessors, associations, and other counterparties may establish maximum deductible requirements as part of financing or contractual agreements.
That can create a practical mismatch at placement. A broker may identify an overlying property program that offers the appropriate wildfire capacity and pricing, but the wildfire deductible is higher than a lender will accept. Deductible buyback can provide a way to address the retained layer without requiring the primary carrier to restructure an otherwise viable placement.
3. It preserves the primary carrier's wildfire structure
On the underwriting side, these products can provide substantial underwriting benefits. The buyback does not ask the overlying carrier to take back first-dollar wildfire exposure that it intentionally transferred to the insured through the deductible. Instead, the overlying carrier can continue underwriting the property at its chosen attachment point. A specialty buyback market separately evaluates the retained wildfire layer, prices that exposure, and determines how much of it it is prepared to assume.
By separating the retained wildfire layer from the primary policy, brokers can preserve an otherwise effective property placement while addressing the portion of risk the client may not want to keep on its own balance sheet
4. Indemnity tied to the actual wildfire loss
Wildfire Deductible Buyback is an indemnity structure, which means its response is tied to actual covered loss rather than an external index trigger. For commercial insureds, that creates a direct relationship between the damage the client experiences and the insurance intended to address the deductible.
The linkage between damage and client experience doesn’t mean policy coordination can be ignored. Brokers need to understand how the buyback wording interacts with the underlying contract, including the covered cause of loss, deductible calculation, insured values, property covered, business-income treatment where applicable, loss adjustment, and other terms that determine whether and how the layer responds.
5. A defined layer of catastrophe exposure
The buyback structure also creates a clearly defined maximum amount at risk. If the policy provides $450,000 of wildfire deductible buyback, that layer does not grow simply because the total property loss increases from $1 million to $5 million or $10 million.
For the buyback underwriter, the frequency and location of wildfire loss becomes especially important. Property-level characteristics, local wildfire conditions, protection features, geographic concentration, and portfolio aggregation all become important inputs in deciding where and at what price the coverage can be offered.

What brokers should evaluate at renewal
Wildfire Deductible Buyback will not be the right solution for every client. Some insureds have the liquidity and risk tolerance to retain a larger wildfire deductible, while others may be able to negotiate a lower deductible from the primary carrier at a price that makes separate coverage unnecessary.
Brokers should look closely at accounts with a material wildfire-specific deductible, an insured that would prefer not to finance the entire retention, a lender or contractual maximum deductible, and an underlying property placement that otherwise meets the client's needs. A softer market can make deductible buyback more cost-effective, giving brokers another way to reduce a client’s wildfire retention without unnecessarily increasing total program cost.
Percentage wildfire deductibles deserve particular attention because the dollar exposure may not be obvious when terms are first presented. Converting the deductible into an actual dollar amount allows the broker and insured to have a more useful conversation about liquidity, risk tolerance, and the economics of buying down part of the exposure.
Help your clients manage wildfire deductibles with Index Risk
The increased interest in Wildfire Deductible Buyback reflects a broader change in how catastrophe risk is being divided among carriers and insureds. As primary markets use more granular wildfire underwriting and larger retentions to manage their exposure, some insureds will need a separate solution for the portion of wildfire risk that remains on their balance sheet.
Where wildfire deductibles create a meaningful financial or contractual challenge, Index Risk can help wholesale brokers evaluate whether its Wildfire Deductible Buyback product is an appropriate solution.



